Gooey on the Inside Cookies

I ordered these through Goldbelly so can’t comment on how the cookies are when you actually eat them fresh. I was pretty disappointed in the cookies I received in the mail. They looked decent but when I heated them up they were nothing like what I was expecting. The inside was not gooey at all, it was just a weirdly warm semi firm dough. It had very little flavor and was not pleasant to eat, I ended up throwing most of it in the garbage. I spent $40 on 6 cookies, would not purchase again (unless maybe it was fresh from the store). Goldbelly won’t let me leave a review so I am leaving one here with the hope it might help someone else who decides to have them shipped.

Delicious...really crunchy on the outside and gooey cookie dough inside. I got the birthday cake which has white chocolate in it. I like it as it's mild. Also got the chocolate chip. Really rich cookies. $5. per cookie. Just be careful when you go in, there a couple of areas that could be a trip hazard.

If 0 stars was an option, that would actually be more accurate. I waited 3 weeks for the peanut butter gooey on the inside cookies I ordered. They were neither peanut butter nor gooey....more consistent with sand. Could not be more disappointed.

Worst over-priced cookies I have ever had. There are a very few amount of chocolate chips inside the cookie, mostly you are eating the dough only. The dough also smells and tastes like its not well cooked. The taste is ridiculous and the cookies are wayyyyyyyy over-priced for $5. There are better cookies available for $4 a piece and less, that have a lot more chocolate chips/chunk inside and tastes like a chocolate chip cookie. Definitely never going back here to waste $5.

Lovely little shop that can be hard to miss. Quick and fast service for yummy huge cookies.

Absolutely incredible cookies. They are both super creative but also very very good. The Dunkaroo cookie Incorporated the cookies themselves as well as the icing. And they're just slightly undercooked to be exactly what the name states, gooey on the inside!

The cookies are warm, delicious and not too sweet. I would post the picture, but they're already in my tummy. Nevertheless, it's Definitely worth the visit. Great service as well.

The people there are very nice and the cookies are amazing. A great shop although not very big and noticeable

Cookies are huge and tasty! Personally, a bit too sweet for me but it’s a cute place to try out!

One of the best cookie chips shop in NYC😋 chocolate chunk cookie is great for sure, red velvet cookie is amazing too! And the price is sweet

WOW!!! I’m blown away.. These are what cookies are supposed to be. Most delicious and enjoyable cookie ever.. Any flavor is amazing.. Hats off to the bakers..,

I absolutely love sweets, but these were too sweet even for me. I gave them a try multiple times and each gave me a stomach ache after only a few bites. Too rich, too sweet, not my favorite.

If you’re not paying attention you may walk or ride right by this place and not know it was there. As I was standing outside a young lady said she’s been living up the street for 6 years and never knew that such delicious, yummy for your yummy cookies were right there. I’m eating a chocolate chip cookie that’s literally as thick as my finger, and it’s really good. And yes it’s warm and gooey on the inside. If I had some cold milk, I would’ve eaten two or three.

The cookie was alright. I went at happy hour and they didn't give me the discount because I didn't ask for it. Can't blame them but still.. three stars