Gatsby's Pizza & Pub

We had coupons for a free slice of pizza and they honoured it. Only paid for the toppings and the.pizza couldn't.be.beat for a crunchy flat crust. All four of us raved about it. The bruchetta was great too. Atmosphere also. Menu was.limited. That was the only con

My friend and I went there on chance and I was amazed. Greg was a kind man that shows he truly has a love for what he's doing. The place had this comforting feeling and the pizza was spectacular. I will definitely go back.

Love it! Reminds me of home! Some wonderful people that own the place! Keep up the great work!

Not there anymore

Loved the pizza! Thin and Crispy with light sauce. Reasonably priced.Jackie greeted us upon arrival and Greg shared his amazing story of perserverance with brain cancer.

Fantastic Pizza!Read about this place in the newspaper and had to check it out because of the story behind the owners. Cute little place with a homey atmosphere. Small menu but it's perfect. The pizza is delicious! The crust is thin and crunchy. Personal recipe; same with the sauce made fresh daily. Greg the owner visited tables and is sooo happy to be making pizzas again. You MUST check it out!

Still after all challenges !FANTASTIC !!!!

Thin crispy crust with the best toppings. Pepperoni and cheese or sausage green pepper and onion are our favorites. Great service from the delightful owner Greg as well! It's a wonderful experience and so close to the beach, what more could you ask for? If you are in the area and you love fresh pizza you have to give it a try.

Extremely expensive for a pizza that tasted like cardboard. The crust tasted as though it had saw dust in it. The toppings were good. This place should be avoided at all cost.Perhaps if they are out of business a good joint can replace them. The crust could not be worse!

Love their pizza. Greg, the Owner, is the nicest guy, and makes everyone feel like family.

Best pizza in the state of Florida

The pizza sauce was incredible and the atmosphere here is very friendly as the owners greet you as you come in the door. Makes being a Buckeye feel at home from so far away.

An old tried and true establishment reopened. The pizza is as good as ever and better than any other I've tried. Greg Gzstby, the owner always great you with a warm hello and makes you feel like an old dear friend. He puts his love into every part of the business and it shows. If you really love pizza it's a dining delight.

Eating Gatsby's Pizza right now. Just had a great conversation with the owner who is absolutely delightful and friendly. We're from NY, and I will say- this is not NY Style pizza. It is entirely different, but delicious in its own right. Thin and crispy and loaded with super fresh toppings. The slices are tiny squares instead of the standard triangle- which means I probably ate too many too fast without realizing it, lol. It is yummy.We did carry out, but there were a few tables in the restaurant. Everything seemed clean and it was nicely decorated. And did I mention friendly? I will definitely return here on our next trip to Florida. Thank you, Greg, for your hospitality!

I love the staff! Greg and Jackie are so nice. I dont live far and have been eating takeout or delivery from there every week since the lockdown. Ive earned a free pizza and it was amazing! This place is a diamond. Thanks Gatsbsys!