Five Pennies Creamery

The owner really loves his job. The ice cream is amazing.

Lots of fun flavors to taste. Staff is fun and friendly. Clean. Reasonable prices. Offer a huge Sundae for a group to share. Seating space available to enjoy ice cream inside. I had the banana pudding flavor with strawberry topping Mmmmm

Delicious..

Strolled in after the wife and I had cravings for ice cream. We each got 2 scoops each and may have under estimated the scoops sizes. Black cherry vanilla was so fluffy and creamy. The pralines was so flavorful I think my Blood sugar was at an all time high. I would go back definitely.

Yum! Unbelievable ice cream. We tried Banana Pudding, Rum Raising, Toasted Coconut, Smurfs and Chocolate Birthday Cake. They were rich, velvety and all had incredible big flavor. HIGHLY RECOMMEND! To top it off they have a wonderful staff and were playing the Beatles the whole way through.

Ice cream was good but nothing stood out as exceptional

Best ice cream...especially cookies and cream. And the staff is just the nicest!

Staff was friendly and helpful. Nice place to get some icecream, WILL Definitely be back for more laughs and good icecream

In my personal opinion this is the best ice cream on the island. The staff is very friendly and patient. They have a wide variety of great flavors, its very tough to choose just one. Try the banana pudding and peanut butter !

My favorite flavor wasn't on display but when I showed my Virginia ID the owner himself found a pint of it. They have the best customer service in ANYANY industry. They 6 deserve stars

The icecream here is smooth and creamy. Ordered a sundae with the works. Very children friendly atmosphere. The shop has an old school feel to it. But a new family favorite.

Many different flavors, you have to try the banana pudding.

Best ice cream for local and fresh with a variety of flavors. Worth the trip and there is so much else to do in the area.

I Fell InLove Love 😍 with the Oreo Peanut Butter with Crunchies, and the Coconut Cane . The Best Mom and Pops Icecream Store in LI with many unique and One of Kind Flavors. Sweet staff gave recommendations.

Wonderful place for ice cream! They do shakes, sundaes, cones, and even cakes. Friendly and helpful staff allow a lot of sampling so you are sure you're getting what you like best. Plenty of flavors of a constantly changing menu. Yes, the price is a bit high for a single scoop, but it evens out quite once you move to a 2 or 3 scoop item. This is a place where you come for quality, not bargain prices. And, to be fair, they usually give quite a big scoop. Certainly this isn't the place to come when you are counting calories or pennies, but it is the place to come when you want amazing ice cream! If they have the peppermint patty ice cream, try it, it's my favorite and never in stock often enough!