First Slice Pie Cafe

Amazing peanut butter pie and sour cherry pie in a cozy shop

I absolutely adore this place! The staff are super friendly and helpful, they were great about checking ingredients for my obscure allergy, and the food and pies are to die for! They also give back to the community, which is fantastic!

Best pie ever. Also, make sure to grab a cinnamon bullseye to go!

Love coming here. They have a variety of delicious pies (standard and unique flavors) as well as a range of options. I'm fond of their tamales, but the lasagna is fantastic as well. Friendly staff!

If you’re here around Thanksgiving: stop what you’re doing and go get a pumpkin cheesecake from the fridge. It’s seriously the best thing ever.

The space is small and, at least when I was there on a Friday evening, it was quiet. I had the pear goat cheese something sandwich, which was delicious and served with a hearty portion of chips and a side salad of very fresh greens and radishes and onion and vingrette. Pie was of course delicious! I had sour cherry--as pretty as it was tasty, and my friend had French silk--huge and obviously filled with quality ingredients and care. Service was great too for a counter service place.

Tried the key lime and traditional Apple.Good pies, nice quaint restaurant, and friendly staff.

Amazing pie and coffee, and the cafe itself is super cozy! Great place to study!

My friends and I went in rather close to closing (sorry about that) and ordered some slices to go. The key lime pie was simply delicious! It was the best key lime pie id had in years! The girl at the register was wonderful too, all smiles and very cheerful! Will definitely be going back here as a return customer!

Hidden gem! Best apple pie ever. Curry chicken salad was delicious.

The pie was excellent and the service was prompt and very friendly!

Really good sandwiches and fun hipster atmosphere. Service was pretty quick even though there was a large crowd there. That being said, the place is small so it feels a little claustrophobic at times.

Their food legitimately seems like it was made with lots of love. I came in for the sweet onion and bacon quiche, and my partner had a cucumber chicken sandwich. Both were amazing, and you can tell that the ingredients were super fresh. The staff here (Mac helped us) is super kind and accommodating, and took their time to give us recommendations. Will DEFINITELY be ordering thanksgiving pie here in the future too. Great neighborhood find!

Every Christmas I buy my wife the $25 cherry pie this place makes!This place is worth every cent

Best pie in the city! Their french silk is to die for! ❤