Loading...

Emmett's

Recommended Reviews

5
72%
4
10%
3
0%
2
8%
1
8%
4.3
48 reviews
😍
Stewart Bachan
2018-10-07 on google

You don’t need to go to Chicago for great deep dish pizza! Great food and friendly staff makes this a great spot for lunch or dinner!

😍
Scott Sanchez
2018-10-07 on google

Great choice for Chicago style deep dish pizza in nyc. One 10” and a couple of beers for 2 people is plenty of food, unless you’re starving, then I’d recommend the 12”. Staff is friendly and the 80s vibe is great without feeling manufactured.

😀
Alexander Negron
2018-10-04 on google

Friendly staff, they seam eager to accommodate. The place is a little small, even the people at the bar where trying to get us a seat. Ordered mozzarella sticks four sticks came, and they where delicious. The pizza is amazing, great taste. If you think papa johns, and dominos is great pizza then this place isn't for you. Good selection of beers. If your in the area, and have a taste for pizza this is definitely worth a visit.

😍
Reuben Brown
2018-10-02 on google

Emmett's was fantastic, went here three weeks ago with my family and loved the deep dish. We are English and would love a deep dish place to open in the United Kingdom

😍
Andy Chana
2018-09-10 on google

One of the top, most fun ambiances in Soho for dining. An absolute gem. The quality of the pizza is A+, best cheese, sauce, and toppings. The wine and beer list is outstanding as well!

😐
Patrick
2018-08-16 on google

Know this place is good... Delivery tasted like digiorno :/ but will come back because I know I must’ve gotten a bad pie!

😍
L Callaway
2018-07-20 on google

Justin, is phenomenal! Additionally, I arrived in the nick of time to order a delicious burger that he recommended. Justin even assured me that the rat hanging on the curb just wanted to bum a smoke. Philly women definitely aren't use to that! Can’t wait to visit the city again and Emmet’s! 💪🏽

😍
Andrea
2018-07-17 on google

Excellent deep dish pizza! This seating is limited, and there may be a wait time, but it's worth it!

😐
Rangsey Keo
2018-07-13 on google

Overcrowded tiny place with a 1hour wait time for mediocre pizza is not my idea of a good meal.I went there because I've never tried deep dish pizza, but the experience was underwhelming. I'm sure real Chicago style pizza tastes better than that dry thing we got that could never compete with even the dollar pizza dotted all over NYC.I will give an additional star for the floor manager who was quick, understanding, and absolutely courteous. The only credit the owner or store manager gets is for hiring her.

😍
Mansi Jain
2018-06-22 on google

Emmett's is my go-to place for deep dish pizza in new york. It's a tiny cozy place I like to go to with my boyfriend for a nice long romantic dinner. They take about 30 mins to prepare the pizza, which gives us ample time to have nice conversations with really good salad and wine. I recommend booking in advance as its always mostly full, no matter what time of the week.

😍
Karim D
2018-06-18 on google

When you think about NY pizza you don't think about deep dish, but Emmett's changes that all. What a delicious deep dish and it's done right. Just like a pie, sauce on top, and a total fork and knife experience. The staff is super friendly too. Can't wait to come back to NY for some deep dish. Who would have thought?!

😍
Muhieddine Itani
2018-06-17 on google

Deep dish or this crust are both great. But I go there specifically for the deep dish. Curated wine selection! Very friendly and phenomenal service!

😕
Jared Shull
2018-05-20 on google

Placed an order on the phone and when I arrived to pick up my order was informed that the order ticket never got sent to the kitchen. No offer was made to offer a discounted or free pizza, which is the only way I was going to wait around for 40 minutes for my order to be made. Can’t recommend anyone order from here if these types of mistakes are going to happen.

😀
Kristina Lim
2018-05-18 on google

One of the few places in New York City that serves Chicago style pizza.

😍
Graham Harwood
2018-05-05 on google

I cannot recommend Emmett's enough. I am from Chicago and I love Chicago style pizza. When I moved to NYC I naturally got into heated discussions about the obvious superiority of Chicago style to other types of pizza. I win this argument by taking people to Emmett's. I usually do takeout because getting a table isn't easy. I took the pizza to a byof bar and everyone kept stopping and asking where I got it.

Questions & Answers

The menu said till 6p
Top