Cosmo's Pizzeria

We ordered a late lunch takeout after a hike, as places weren’t allowed to be open due to Covid-19. Their subs are really good. The sub rolls are fresh and toasted a little crispy. The Turkey is great, my dad liked the Italian. Their pizza is very good too although it was a touch overdone. Look forward to being able to go back when we can dine in. They seem to have a good system for takeout - markings on floor, mask when you pickup the food, one door in, one door out. Will probably get it again this trip. Thanks.

Fantastic pizza and great customer service. We got home and found out our pizza was made incorrectly, and the staff offered to make and DELIVER a new one. Absolutely delicious, and the service to correct their mistake earned them a repeat customer.

Open sign was out front of the door, so we went in for lunch. Owner gave us quite the attitude inform us that they were to the contrary, closed. Open sign out front and front door is unlocked... Honest mistake. Doesn’t require you being an asshole about it.

Want some pizza? This place has it. Despite some very angry patrons saying their pizza took over two hours, we had 15 people served in under an hour. Unfortunately, we had to wait about a half hour to be sat because they were slammed with carry out orders, so a half empty dining room sat open at 7pm on Saturday night. Once we sat, a few beers from the bar took longer than the food to be poured, even though the bar was half empty. It was bizarre. The pizza hit the spot - it was pizza. I understand we were here during the busiest weekend of the year, but it seems like Cosmo's should bring in a bit more help to get their bar responsive to patrons in the dining room. We would have definitely had another round or two of drinks had we gotten them more quickly.On the plus side, our server was super nice and the front of house staff (beyond the bartender) seemed to be doing the best they could and remained cheerful, despite the mismanagement.

We loved this place! Excellent pizza, excellent fries, and an amazing Italian sub! Our boys said it's one of the best pizzas they've ever eaten!

In here tonight from Ohio.. good food and service from Cosmo's... We ordered twice as much as we needed to take a full pizza back to our beach house.. will be here again in the future when we visit OBX again. I read some bad reviews but people don't put all things into consideration before they cut a shop up.. I really don't believe 95%of them.. keep up the good pizzaria

WOW! We got in late and were looking for a quick bite of dinner and picked Cosmo's at random... turns out to be some of the best pizza you'll ever taste! Worth a meal or 6 if you are in the area.

Amazing food amazing service the waiter was nice the host was nice!

Good service and great pizza. Family-friendly dining. Worth the stop.

Great pizza and bread sticks. Lovely service. Accessibility isn't great, but it's a stop for us every year we come here.Edit: Wheelchair accessibility. I don't think you've failed in anyway, just parking and entrances a little tight around the tables. For most people it's not a huge deal, but our daughter has mobility issues so I try to give a heads up to other patrons in case their needs are more severe.

We got a small pizza and breadsticks. Pizza was good, breadsticks with marinara were outstanding. Service was great.