Colonial Pie Company

I just got a large pepperoni pizza and it was delicious. Haven't had a dessert pie from them in a year or so but they're good too.

Swang by for a Father's Day treat and the key lime pie was perfect. Not too tart but still that bite of lime that's great for a summer day. The chocolate pecan was also awesome (if you don't love it you're broke). The man running the place was really nice and just rattled of what was in the case and what he could cut for us. The kids loved the ice cream and I know he threw an extra scoop on for them. If you are in the area definitely seeing by, maybe grab a slice to eat while you ride the ferry.

My Husband & I stopped in for the first time yesterday, which was a beautiful 72-degree January day. The owner was as kind as he could be, & we ordered several items to take home, but enjoyed the baklava, which was fantastic, while sitting outside on the patio watching the birds.Since we had never been here before, we ordered several tarts & pie slices to share at home until we could decide which ones to order as entire pies. Which turned out to be a terrible idea b/c we couldn't narrow it down: they were ALL FABULOUS! The Key-Lime pie was good. The Bumble-berry & Chocolate-Pecan pie was my Husband's favorite; & the Chocolate-Pecan & Coconut pie were by far my favorite! They were absolutely to-die-for delicious! We also got a jar of Bumble-berry (blueberry, raspberry, & blackberry) jam. This is our new favorite go-to place for pie's (which is my personal guilty-pleasure!). The prices are very reasonable, & we will DEFINITELY be back for more... Often. Yum...😋

Pretty damn good apple pie!

It's 75 degrees out, sunny, and you're sitting on a picnic table bench eating a personal-sized strawberry-peach pie in the shade while watching native butterflies flutter around. There's nothing complicated or strange about pie and they make a good one, too. This is a place of no embarrassment. It's easy to spot, there is ample parking, and you can people/car watch as the world goes by.

Great pie and pot pie but I'm sure about the pizza it could be frozen

My husband and I love the Dagwood hoagie!!

Small building so it's just take out, but oh so good. Worth the stop.

They make the best baklava!

This little shop has the tastiest pies. The owner is very friendly also. We wanted to try different kinds and every one of them turned out to be delicious. If you are out of state I would recommend peanut pie.

We stopped by for a late lunch after our day at the Jamestown settlement. We had a large Sicilian which was very good. The cheese fries were great too but we had to eat fast as the weather outdoors made the melted mozzarella coagulate real fast. The girl behind the counter was very friendly. Will definitely be back.

Best pecan pie I've ever had. Very great service as well.

The Baklava was out of this world!

We stopped in today because of the amazing reviews. The food was phenomenal! We had a sausage and pepperoni pizza and an Italian! Well worth it. No indoor seating but it was cool enough to sit outside. Great little place. We will absolutely come again when visiting!

This place is great pecan is delicious not as sweet as a traditional pecan pie which I like