Cerrone's Brick Oven Pizzeria

We stumbled upon the Smokin Cerrone pizza a few weeks ago from our favorite pizza shop, Cerrone's. In fact, we can't get this pie out of our heads. It is my #1 choice from them now. Cerrone's pizza crust is always AMAZING and the quality of the ingredients is one you can taste. This location and pizza is one you simply must try!!

Excellent quality ingredients! Fresh and tasty and a real family pleaser. Looking forward to trying more of the menu! Thank you to the friendly staff for providing quality food in our cities time of need. Support your local Cerrone's. You will not be disappointed.

Great authentic NY style pizza! We had the spicy Hawaiian. You can taste the freshness of all of the ingredients and can tell that the dough and sauce are from scratch. Best pizza we've had in a very long time!

I’ve eaten here in person two different time and one from delivery. The times in person were 2017 and the pizza was fantastic. Had the delivery April 2020 and it was not so great. The crust was chewy on both pizzas and just barely tasted better than a frozen pie. It could be the ingredients took a hit because of the pandemic. I’ll give them another try later in the year. It could be that it’s amazing served fresh from the oven but once it cools down some it turns awful. I think my latest experience is just a one-off. However, it was somewhat awful pizza. If you have gotten their pizza recently and it was delicious then I just got a bad batch of dough.

Not too bad for a local place. The service is very attentive, and the pizza was good. The layout makes climate control a bit challenging. While you would think grabbing a table by the kitchen would be hot from the ovens, the temperature is actually cooler than the front (still a bit uncomfortably warm). The crust of the pizza is the best part, and our entire pie was well made, nicely cooked and crispy.

Hands down the best pizza place in Columbus. This is one of the best pizza places I've ever been to, for that matter. Delicious, chewy crust and flavorful toppings. The square pizza gives you extra crust to enjoy. Old world style is awesome because the sauce and crust are king. Go with something simple vs something with a bunch of toppings. The garlic knots are awesome and the craft beer selection is decent. You have to eat here.

Good Pizza Hut definitely more pricy than a lot of the other pizzerias in town. My wife thought it was a little too greasy. We also had garlic bread, which looks like a small pizza itself, and the Greek salad. The salad was large enough that all of us wound up eating some of it. We went on a Friday night when the place was hopping. It’s a small place so seating can be a problem at peak times. We got a table quickly but had to scrounge for chairs since someone had taken a couple of the chairs from our table. Some of our group felt a little claustrophobic with the small space and the crowd.Staff was very friendly and the food was good. I’d definitely go back.