Restaurants near Casey's New Buffalo

Subway

"The platters are amazing and done picture perfect.. hats off to the manager."

Brewster's Italian Cafe

Beachside Scoops

"The best ice cream place in New Buffalo. Amazing flavors, employees, owners, and experience. All the employees welcome you with open arms. The price is also amazing much better than Oinks. VIBE CHECK..."

The Stray Dog Bar & Grill

"Review in times of COVID-19: so, I am adjusting my reviews to more accurately convey the experience of the places I “tried” during the pandemic. The food at The Stray Dog was nice, not pretentious..."

Beer Church Brewing Co.

"The atmosphere was really nice. Church benches were used for seating. There was a outdoor seating available. We got the cheese and meet plate. The selection was nice. There was a variety of beer t..."

Oink's Dutch Treat

"My boyfriend and I love this wonderful experience called Oinks!! We make a trip there 3-4 times a month! And we live in Elkhart IN!! The service is always superior and the ice cream is the BEST EVER!!..."

The Lakehouse Pub

"Nice place to grab a bite. Food was good. Service was excellent. Prices were very reasonable. Will definitely go here again."

Song asian Cusine

"Standard US Chinese restaurant menu coupled with a better-than-a-grocery-store sushi bar and a bunch of Japanese selections.AND THEY DELIVER!The fact that I can get I can get Mongolian beef, egg rolls..."

New Buffalo Bill's Wood Fired Bbq

"We stopped here for lunch and we both had a great meal. I had the two item combo with brisket and pulled pork along with cowboy beans and mac and cheese. The brisket was fall apart tender and had a gr..."

Bentwood Tavern

"Always great food atmosphere and service from chefs Jenny and Alberto to the hosts. Rich and Rose will always love this symbol of dining excellence in the Harbor Country region"

Pizza Hut

"The food and service was great...."

I CAN Cafe

"Nice time there. Was my first time today. My friend enjoyed the wine tasting. Very unique choices from Israel and other places. Great place to try oils & vinegar. The coffee shop was very clean and co..."

Ghost Isle Brewery

"Glad we made a stop at this cool new place! Good beer and great food! It's pretty big on the inside and was pretty busy for a dreary and cool June Wednesday."

Roma Pizza

McDonald's

"Great friendly employees at this restaurant. Food was hot and fresh. The sundaes were loaded with hot fudge better than most I've been too. Clean dinning area and restrooms make a enjoyable dinning ex..."

Subway

"Both the manager and employee were very busy as could be, but were freindly and attentive to everyone who entered. Very quick lunch stop and it was fast, efficient, and delicious. Thanks ladies."

Copper Rock Steakhouse

"Service is absolutely fantastic! Food is great, and the atmosphere is friendly. One of my favorite places to indulge."

Skip's Restaurant & Catering

"This place is amazing. I don't have enough food things to say about it. The staff is great and fast. The food is fresh and delicious. The potions and the prices are great as well. It's an authentic Vi..."