Casey's New Buffalo

Been eating at Casey's on and off for years. It's a 90 mile trip from my house, so unless I'm in that (Michigan) area for some reason or another, the awesome tasting food of Casey's is a 'maybe monthly' event. My main point is, you won't be disappointed in a visit to Casey's. Enjoy! (Wish I lived closer, ha, ha,)

Not bad. Enjoyed the food. Place was short staffed but they did well. Was not busy and did good.

Highly recommend the perch sandwich. Three pieces of fish, very generous portion. The crab cakes were also very good. Cheddar fondue unique, pretzels seemed deep fried and not enough of them for the cheese. Our server seemed new and lacked knowledge about the menu.

This place was great! We were traveling through and stopped in this weekend. They were pretty busy so it was slow initially to get a server but once they came to our table the service was as to be expected for a bar/grill type restaurant on a Saturday night. The buffalo wrap was SO good! The sweet potato waffle fries were also perfect. My boyfriend had a burger and fries and thought they were both excellent. Really great bar food! We come to the area frequently and will definitely stop in again!

Always excellent. I love going out and seeing Phil and everyone at Casey's. Great spot

They did a great job with online ordering and curbside pickup, unfortunately the food on this visit left a lot to be desired. Things had good flavor, but the chicken was very tough (difficult to bite into), and the sweet potato fries were undercooked. Tried to take them back, but by the time we drove back they had closed. Took the fries home and put them in the oven to finish cooking. ***We heard from them the very next day, and they are going to make things right. We look forward to trying Casey's again soon. Great customer service, even in these difficult times where we are all having to learn how to do things differently!***

The food was pretty good, just took a long time to take the food orders. The wait for the food was expected since they were pretty busy. If I'm ever in the area I would give them another go.

Tasty food, but way too under-staffed. The bartender ended up having to wait tables. The bartender didn't seem frazzled by overload of customers per waitress ratio like I would have been. She was friendly. The food was delicious, we each ordered the pick 3 combo. We all enjoyed our meals, and the wait was understandable considering the staffing was decreased. On a cold day, it was a nice treat to have a sandwich and hot clam chowder.

Great food. Friendly service. A little pricey

Dirty bathrooms and the food was gross. I wish they took pride in the food. Could have been a awesome place

Bathroom sinks don't work, can't wash your hands. 1 waiter he was good but the only one for the whole restaurant. Steak sandwich was roast beef. Sides came after we were done eating.

As bar food goes, it was very good. I had the Buffalo chicken wrap with BBQ sauce instead of Buffalo sauce. It was very yummy.

Nice tavern right on the strip with a great beer garden and good bar food.

Only stopped in for a Chardonnay for my wife and a Craft Beer for me. A large bridal party came in right before us. The bartender was able to handle the large party and cater to us as well! 2 thumbs up for her!!

Great food. Great atmosphere. Service was okay. I highly recommend the crispy buffalo wings and the beer cheese fondue.