Carnegie NY Style Pizza, Rolls, & Bowls

Dry margarita pizza, completely dry. Other pizzas I bought no one liked, they were greasy. Chocolate mousse is a cake with chocolate icing, tastes like it came from a grocery store. For the amount of money being charged it’s not worth it I’m sorry, overpriced for no reason. Tried something new and it didn’t work out. Will stick to mod pizza for better quality, made fresh and for less.

Everything about this pizza place reminds of on NEW YORK. The pizza and the atmosphere is amazing. This is a great family friendly restaurant that caters to kids, tastes great and won’t break the bank. I highly recommend this place.

Ordered half and half pizza along with Garlic knots. During my previous visit I liked the garlic knots, so I thought I will order it along with pizza. Garlic knots were not fully cooked. On the inside we literally tasted dough while on the outside it looked crispy, making it impossible to eat. The pizza was underwhelming as well with the veggies still raw and clearly undercooked. I had high expectations on this place, but unfortunately did not have a good experience.

This beautiful place has all authentic food. I ordered Philly Cheesesteak sandwich and it was the best I have ever tasted in my life. Amazing food! Great people! Great service! Highly recommend!!!

I had a terrible experience here, I would strongly urge people to choose literally any other pizza place. Staff was dismissive and angry, my order took much longer than I was told it would, cooks weren’t using basic health and hygiene practices. I feel lucky not to have gotten food poisoning and won’t eat there again.

Awesome Pizza especially plain cheese. If you like New York style pizza this I'd the place to go. Pastas are outstanding as well. Owner is very personable and will get to know you on a first name basis if you frequent the establishment. Highly recommend it!

Food is tasty but expensive.

High quality food and service! Large portions and very flavorful! Highly recommend!

Tried to call, but there phone number is not in service.

This is by far the best pizza I’ve ever had. I’m picky and I’ve had NY style pizza in NYC. This is incredible. They have beef (halal) pepperoni. Their crust is soooo good. It’s fluffy and chewy and crispy all at the same time. I would highly recommend!!!

Really good service!

I'm down grading the 5 stars to 3 stars due to repeated inconsistencies. After reordering the Mediterranean Chicken Salad about 10 times, the quality is trending downwards. Instead of including mixed greens the chef includes more and more iceberg lettuce... essentially, exclusively ice berg. If I ask for spinich, I now get six to eight spinach leaves on top of a field of ice berg lettuce (see attached image). Usually they include a slice garlic bread (which is really tasty) but it wasn't included this time. Not only is the product inconsistent, but so are the prices. While the prices are relatively competitive, the pricing and "deals" are inconsistent between the paper menu, the signage on the building, the live-response from a phone call I made and the store's website. I hope the new owner is able to overcome the inconsistencies as the unmet expectations really detract from the experience. I'll order from them again, sure, but maybe they need some time to standardize their product and pricing. ----------------- the review was 5-stars I highly recommend the Mediterranean Chicken Salad. While it comes with a side dressing, the side dressing is unnecessary. It's that good. The garlic bread is zesty and delicious. It's quite filling, tasty, healthy and (still) quite affordable ~$12.

Friendly staff, with fast service. I was in the mood for a Gyro, and it was delicious! Thank you!

Service & food were excellent! Food was made fresh & great portion sizes. We will definitely be back!

Good NY style pizza. Pastas are great as well. Staff is friendly and professional.