Cafe La Bellitalia

Always great service and food! Highly recommend!

This place is wonderful! My son, his girlfriend and I had dinner there last night. The food was delicious. The portions were generous. The service was outstanding. Everyone there was so welcoming and made us feel like we were old friends or family. We just felt good being there. Sinatra as the background music was perfect. I cannot say enough good things about Cafe la Bellitalia. We will definitely be back!

One of my favorite date spots. Haven't eaten anything here I haven't loved and pricing is reasonable. Great for take-out, too.

Come here if you want real Italian meal- the apps, dinner AND dessert- all superb! Don't be fooled by the modest exterior of the building-you'll take in the exuberance once you cross the threshold. We were greeted by a spunky and enthusiastic hostess and served by a fun and generous server. We left with belly aches because we couldn't stop eating the deliciousness.

As a fairly frequent visitor and a fair amount of delivery services I could not be more happy to support Cafe LaBellitalia with a review. The food is terrific (do not miss the Tiramisu), the service great and the atmosphere perfect for a casual date night or a special occasion! Prices are fair and wine is good too. We love it! Can't wait to go back!

Phoebe is a fantastic waitress! Best we have ever had! Food is always fanatic!

You will never be disappointed with the food and service.

If I have one word for Cafe la Bellitalia, it’s WOW! I had low expectations going in, but that was my biggest mistake. We went on a Saturday night, and it was packed so we waited around 10 minutes. The service was a little slow, but they were very friendly so it wasn’t big problem. The food came out after 30 minutes and we were given complimentary garlic bread in the meantime. The restaurant itself is pretty small, but doesn’t feel cramped. We ordered a specialty pizza (can’t remember the name) and also the sampler platter. The pizza, with no exaggeration, was the best I’ve have in a restaurant before. The large was plenty for two people. The sampler platter was delicious and was huge for the price. We also got the tiramisu for dessert, which I would highly recommend! For such a small restaurant, it packs a big punch in terms of flavor. Don’t underestimate this hidden Madison gem! We’ll be back!

Love this place, great romantic spot for date night. Good food, friendly staff

Absolutely delicious. My clothes smelled like good food for a week. No more need be said.

Super friendly staff. Great food. Hidden gem in Madison.

We had pizza, the works and it was wonderful.

Fantastic food. Meatballs are great. Always get extra. Much better food the Benvintos. Friendly staff. Highly recommend going if you haven't small place. Reservations helps on popular nights like friday and Saturday. But reservations are not needed.

Excellent food, environment and the staff is always awesome. Our favorite Italian restaurant.

This spot provides fantastic service as well as enjoyable menu. One of my favourite places around here. The meals arrived rapidly and the rates were reasonable. Recommended.