Brother's Pizza

You get 4 stars for finally getting vegan cheese. But, if you want to keep up with the rest of the world, get 5 stars when you can make me a seitan cheese steak like they have in Philly & Tom's River & Belmar, etc.

The best pizza on Earth, period.

Pretty good pizza. Always bustling. Order online - way better than waiting on the phone.

Best pizza in town! I've been going to Brothers Pizza for years now and it has been consistently good. It is a classic style pizzeria with an outdoor dining section under a beautiful open veranda. They also serve authentic traditional Italian meals, which are also very good. My favorite meals to get here however are their pizza with fresh garlic and sausage and their cheese steaks. Staff is also friendly and kind. Definitely one, if not the, best pizza place in the region.

My favorite place for pizza. Always yummy takeout, eating there is even better.

Love this pizza parlor! A true pizza parlor with great pizza hot out of the oven. Good staff and always busy. Other food options are good as well. Outdoor seating is seasonally available with a wood burning oven to cook the pizzas. I recommend Brothers for a nice sit down pizza pie.

This place has been around since the 70's, and for good reason! It's the best pizza in the area, to be honest. Always fresh, hand tossed, and quality ingredients, and you can take it home or eat it there. If pizza isn't what you're craving at the moment, they have a pretty big menu to choose from, with burgers and cheese steaks, calzones and bolis, down to pastas, seafood and salads. They have a small kids menu for eat-in as well, and they do offer catering. We love this place!

Food is fresh. Pizza is crispy. Orders are listened to. Love that if the staff feels the slice they are giving you is puny, they add a second one at no cost.

Nice neighborhood pizza place. Good food at good pricing.

Brother's Pizza is one of the many fantastic pizzerias in the Hamilton area. There is ample seating available and the staff is very polite and helpful. I was happy to find such a large assortment of slices to choose from behind the counter. This is a big plus in my book. I ended up going with a plain slice and a tomato pie slice. Both slices featured crispy crust and base. The plain had stretchy cheese and a pleasant saltiness with a delicious sauce. The tomato slice also benefited from a rich, flavorful sauce with plenty of spices and a pleasant onion / olive oil taste. The crust and base on the tomato slice were exceptionally tasty. Overall, this is a great spot to try and I would definitely recommend it.

Best decision of my day to go for lunch. Had the Popeye (chicken and spinach). Fries were great. Finished with a mousse. It was so rich, most of it came home.Friends had sandwiches and pizza, everything looked amazing. Sat out back. Great food, great prices.

Very good and very clean

My family and I have gone here for years, but the last 6 months have been disappointing. I bought Bruschetta , got it home and the bread was mushy and the toppings didn’t taste good at all. I had my Mother try it and she agreed. I brought it back and was refunded. This past weekend I ordered a plain Sicilian pie I was shocked of the lack of flavor, it was like we were eating bread with a tomato on top. I’ve just been disappointed over and over. Time to move on. Hope you all have better food!

Outstanding, not from the area, locals gave recommendation and glad they did. Will be my go to place while in town. Wide menu too.

Great food friendly service Brothers pizza is Hamiltons Gem