Blue Mountain Beach Creamery

Love their ice cream. They're busy but fast.

Delicious and expensive place to get a single, double ice cream, lemonade, sorbet, and floats. I highly recommend trying the Key Lime Pie ice cream or the German Chocolate Cake, they are my husband and I favorite.

After watching the sunset we stopped by to have a donut, a hot coffee and an iced coffee. The donut was off the chain!!! Delicious!! The coffee was just alright. It was nice that on a Sunday they stay open so late. I found that to be pretty cool. The young lady working was really nice and quick.

So delicious! No need to say anything else!

Great fresh ice cream. The Superman and Magical Unicorn were a hit with my kids.

A hidden gem that is off the beaten path. The Georgia Peach is a huge winner. The Brownie Batter is also excellent. Dont forget the waffle cone (fresh and crunchy)!!! Highly recommend. Reminder: Cash only

Come early, stay late. Kidding. Come early to beat the rush. Lots of fun flavors.

We love this place! They always have new flavors and they have a fence that my kids love to draw on with chalk. Just don't forget to bring cash.

Love the ice cream and all the wonderful flavors they have there! Whether you're staying at Blue Mountain Beach or just passing through, this place is a MUST to visit!!! It has the look of an old fashioned ice cream shop, along with a fun energy & laid back atmosphere that extends from the beach which is a stone's throw away, and customers leave much happier than when they arrived!

Great ice cream and really good prices!

Great little ice cream shop with good flavors and quick service. The one issue is it is expensive. We had cookies and cream, chocolate, graham cracker, and bourbon truffle. All of them were creamy and delicious with great freshly made waffle cones. We ordered, paid, and had our ice cream in just a few minutes and the provided sidewalk chalk was great for the kids. The prices are high, but this is a destination spot in a tourist area so that should be expected. Our 4 singles and one double with 3 waffle cones was $31.Overall 5 stars despite the price. We would go again!

Nice little ice cream shop. Clean, knowledgeable staff, explaining their offerings. Extensive menu to include designer donuts.