Bleecker Street Pizza

We ordered one with pepperoni and one with special sauce to pick up.They were ready for pick up at the right time and we were able to skip the out-the-door line.Although I couldn't eat them, everyone else said the pizzas were great!

Famous American foods are in this restaurant! Last Sunday, my family and I were having dinner in this place. We felt so happy because the foods were so delicious and mouthwatering. We got home with a big smile on our faces. Very satisfying! Thank you so much! I should strongly recommend you to everyone!

Very casual place to eat. The pizza was great! I suggest the Nonna Maria. This was the cheapest meal we had in NYC and one of the best.

After a few successive days of rich French food a pizza was most welcome. Masaniello didn't disappoint. Nicely cooked thin crust and a plentiful filling. Good service. Would recommend a visit.

Friendly people.The pizza is great. We went with Nona Maria, cheese, mushroom and white. First three were really good. The Nona Maria is just perfect balance of sweet, salt and slightly sour tastes. The mushroom was remarkable in how the whole dough and sauce just worked to enhance the mushroom's flavor.The white was a bit uneventful. The cheese was "just" one of the best cheese slices we've had.

It was my last night in NYC. I was sitting in my hotel room reading pizza reviews looking for someplace close (that I haven’t tried) that was open at 1am. I discovered that Bleecker Street Pizza was open until 2am. I raced to the elevator, sprinted to the subway station, jumped on the 1 train to Christopher St. and quickly found my destination. You couldn’t tell from the street but as soon as I opened the door I could see the place was packed with a line waiting to order at the counter. I started up a conversation with a neighborhood resident who highly recommended the Nonna Maria. I bought a few slices including the Nonna Maria to try a little of everything. The plain cheese was pretty good by itself. The pepperoni was a little greasy and I don’t think it was warmed up fully, but the Nonna Maria was truly a slice of heaven. I regret not buying more and bringing it back with me on the plane back to Indiana. I will be back.

Came with a group of friends and had such a warm welcome from the staff. Not to mention the pizza is some of the best I’ve ever had. Greg even put together a big table for us while we were ordering. We loved visiting with him. Thank you Greg & Bleeker St Pizza for the delicious za and service!

Delicious pizza and fantastic service. The man serving the pizza was very enthusiastic and kind. He seemed very happy to be there and made us feel welcome. As for this pizza, I had the original slice. There is an even coating of cheese throughout unlike some slides which have chunks. I enjoyed the flavor of the cheese very much. The sauce had a nice acidity to it and tied in with the cheese nicely. The crust here stood out. Extremely crispy with a very nice texture, the underside was rough and felt nice in the hand. It seemed like I was getting hungrier the more I ate it was so good. Also, there was no wait which is awesome! Worth a stop if you're in the area. $3 for the slice was more than worth it.

New Yorker pizza during stay in NYC is a must. Thanks to TripAdvisor/GoogleMaps proposals, I knew that must visit place is Bleecker Street Pizza. This is a low-cost so don't worry that it's not fancy. Actually in this case, it's a positive. Place is pretty small but big enough to not to miss it. There is a huge variety of pizzas which you can order as normal pizza or per slice. If you are not sure which one is good, the staff is very friendly and communicative. It was so delicious and the slice were so huge, that we visited this place 3 times during our stay. Credit/debit cards allowed. It's a must visit place in NYC.

So I typically know NY pizza better than the next guy. This spot wasn't on my radar. I went to visit a buddy in West Village and he said this was his spot (he lives close). I told him to order me a pepperoni slice. He said, "No, you gotta try the plain, trust me." I said fine lets do it. AND BOY O BOY WAS HE RIGHT! I am all about keeping an open mind when arguing about the best pizza in NY (this conversation can typically get heated). And I know all the traditional spots and specialty pizza spots. But I gotta say, as far as a plain slice goes, this is the best in Manhattan (my heart lies in Brooklyn with Di Fara for overrall plain slice). Its crispy, not greasy and the crust is noticeably delicious. Good work Adam.

THE MOST DELICIOUS PIZZA! Go with a group and try several types. Be prepared to wait at least an hour or more but it's worth it.

The best pizza in the WORLD 🌎 Came all the way from Adelaide, Australia to experience this and I’m still dreaming about it.

Such an amazing experience!! So much more than a pizza restaurant, it’s a slice of NYC history with a soul. We were greeted by Greg who took photos of our group together while we tried our first slices of NYC pizza! Greg took us around the restaurant and showed us pictures of the history of the place he is so proud of. We took a picture with him as a group with a giant pizza and we will cherish these memories forever. Even if you aren’t looking for a warm incredible hospitable experience (your crazy) the pizza here is phenomenal. It will make you wonder why the other places have customers. Our absolute favorite was the buffalo pizza and just plain cheese and pepperoni. Do yourself a favor, Go. Talk to Greg and let him tell you about his brother who opened up the place. Warms your heart and fills your stomach

Thin crunchy crust, good ratio sauce to cheese. Great atmosphere, lovely host Greg. Definitely “must try” if you in NYC.

Found on YouTube, didn't that was the best of NY, and the deserve the award! If you don't know which slice taste, just take the Nonna Maria! And find Greg, it a truly gentleman