Batter Up Cakes

I sampled cupcakes and cookies, incredible! But the main attraction for me was the German Chocolate Cake they made for me. I don't know what they did to make it, but it was amazing!!! I'm gong back and try a fruit pie next time.

Batter Up goes above and beyond. Not only was our daughter’s graduation cake absolutely beautiful, just what we wanted.... Jerri delivered it early in the morning, was able to make some last minute changes, and gifted us with such a generous blessing... which was just the beginning to a wonderful weekend. Everyone ooohed and awed over the cake and it was beyond scrumptious! A HUGE THANK YOU to Jerri and Batter Up Cakes! We loved it!

My boyfriend and I just visited for the first time. Cupcakes are beyond amazing and customer service is top notch!!! We will certainly be visiting again for our cupcake fix!!!

Very pleased with these cupcakes! Definitely going back!

My family and I always order from Batter Up! We love her work and she’s always so friendly. She’s so talented and makes you so comfortable. Anything you need, ORDER FROM HERE.

This place is AMAZING!! Everyone was super friendly and helpful. They were great with my kids. So many choices. We had a vanilla bean cupcake, strawberry swirl, almond strawberry crostata, maple bacon, and sticky bun. Everything was Devine. The owner was super supportive of the military and gave a military discount. Would recommend to ANYONE!

I was planning a surprise party for my daughter while she is 1000 miles from San Antonio at school. The love and care that went into making her event special is beyond words. The cake was beautiful and very tasty ( I heard) and just perfect for the Gatsby inspired party. This amazing establishment and it’s thoughtful owner thought of everything. She even helped me out and picked up a knife and server for me. I will confidently order from Batter Up Bakery for all of my events in Greeley! Just wish they were in San Antonio!

THE best place for cupcakes and cake. Worth the drive from Fort Collins for just one.

Excellent local bakery, everything is made from scratch and very tasty!

Owners and staff are very friendly and courteous. There is a great selection of flavors and types of desserts, with very cute and neat icings, decorations, presentation, etc. The location is very neat, as it is below ground in a very old-fashioned brick enclosure. Very nice and very kind staff. Always love coming here.

YES YES YES. I cannot express how thankful I am for Jerri! She is amazing and sweet and generous and such a talented baker! She made my wedding cake, my wedding cupcakes (4 different flavors), my sister's wedding cake, my mother-in-law's birthday cake, and my sister's baby shower cake. They are all so yummy, beautiful, and detail-oriented. I will never go to any other cupcake shop/bakery. Service is OUTSTANDING! Love Batter Up, and love Jerri!

Jeri the owner is one amazing person and truly cares about her customers! We had kindof a disaster with a graduation cake we had ordered. However, as soon as Jeri found out she called us, apoligized, refunded our money and offered to make it right. We weren't expecting that and were just going to let it go. Even though our first cake didn't turn out, it's a memory that will make us smile and laugh, maybe not then, but now. But She didnt give up though and Im so glad she didn't. Our second cake was for my daughters baby shower and it turned out perfect. Exactly what we wanted, plus the little elephant on top, although edible, once dry is a keepsake that can be cherished forever. She even made my son a second little cake just because she could. After everything I truly am amazed by her and her bakery. I would use her again and i would recommend her to anyone. She made a customer for life and her biggest cheerleader! Alexis, Michael, Parker, Barry, Jordan and I all Thank-you

We love this place and all the help we always get from Jerri! We got our wedding cake here and always get our bday cakes here too. Every flavor we've tried has been delicious but we really like the strawberry swirl!

The Cake was great! The Service was great! The Staff was so helpful! We traveled to Greeley for UNC graduation from Oregon, so everything was ordered by phone. They were so helpful to work with and the cake was so special. Our Math Major grad was impressed that all of the equations were correct. Thanks to Jerri, Mac & Rachelle you made our visit!

Very tasty chocolate eclair. Perfect temperature and great filling. Just a bit too chewy for me. Could be a personal preference on my part. This is not meant negatively. They gave free samples of very tasty cupcakes. Very friendly and welcoming service.