Bantam Bagels

Stacey and Rosemary were exceptional at the front counter coaching me through this exciting menu as I wanted to bring an assortment to my co-workers. Thank you ladies

Cozy and homey feeling. Adorable staff. Very good variety of flavors and it all taste realy good. A must visit spot.

I tried these at Starbucks and loved them....the only problem was they were very expensive! The only reason i tried them is that i got a gift card. I would love to buy some. Is there any coupons you can send me so i can buy them again? PLEASE THEY WERE SO GOOD. THANK YOU

I have been waiting to try these since they appeared on Shark Tank years ago. I was not going to be in NY and I don’t drink coffee so I knew I wasn’t going to go to Starbucks. I found these at my local grocery store . Long story short these are absolutely delicious. In and out of the oven in 7 minutes . Crispy in the outside and the cream cheese is fabulous. $5 a box I will be buying these again.

Saw the pitch from the founders on Shark Tank, was in NY for vacation, had to stop in for a quick bite. Purchased the classic bagel, delicious! Wonderful customer service, Asha greeted and asked me if I had any questions before purchasing. Will definitely be back 😀

I really liked the concept of this shop. The shop itself is really cute. The only reason I give it a 4 star is because the cream cheese fillings are not as tasty as the bagels are. The bagel is so soft, fluffy and the perfect amount of crispy. The fillings have a faint taste so it's not overwhelming. The bagels are small, cute and easy to eat and not messy!!

I tried those cute little wonder balls for the first time recently. In all honesty, I only tried them because my local Food Lion had them on sale for 2 for $5.00. I got the everything with veggie cream cheese and the plain with regular cream cheese. They were awesome! I went back to the store last night and thought I’d pick up some more. Nope! I’m sorry Bantam Bagels, but your price point is way out of my league. I can’t afford to pay almost $5.00 for one box (6 little bagel balls). So, I won’t be purchasing them in the future unless they go on sale again, or you drop the price. But to anyone out there reading this review, if you can afford them, I highly recommend them! So good!

This is the original store for Bantam Bagels. They specialize in stuffed bagel balls. The offerings range from sweet to savory, so that they can cover breakfast and all other meals or snacks of the day. I wouldn't really go out of my way for it, but I can see it being a destination for buying something unique for a party or picnic. The shop itself is small, doesn't offer a restroom or any space (other than a two person counter and a bench outside) to really sit and enjoy your purchase.We tried a variety of flavors and were not disappointed with any of them. I would certainly consider these unique items as perfect for a picnic.