Antonio's New York Style Pizza

Had lunch here. The gyro was huge. Perfect for two. Hot, tasty, great flavor. Great service. Highly recommend. Took a pizza home to snack on, also very good.

There are two Antonio’s. The one I’m reviewing is the one next to Rita’s. Google only shows location 2. Had the Gyro, loved it. They make there own bread, so it’s like having a thin pizza crust instead of a pita. Makes a great Gyro. They can make thicker pizzasIf you would like. We are from NY but not crazy about foldable pizza. Foldable is ok if your intending to mail your pizza. Will be back for a Custom pie.

I love this lil pizza shop! Don't let the size of the shop fool ya...the pizzas are big and pack big flavor! I came back twice on my vacation. Good pizza is hard to find. Great job!!

I had to come back from NYC to Florida to get some New York style pizza! Hand tossed dough! Amazing pepperoni! Get it hot!

Nice little place to get a bite to eat. Right next to it is an ice cream place. It looked good even though we didn't get to try it this time.

Love there awesome New York Pizza. Try some shrimp on it!! So incredible. The best I ever had

Good pizza conveniently located near the beach for lunch! They have a cheap lunch special too!

Pizza was different in taste from the other places in town, which I liked. Restaurant was dirty (dining room) from the night before (I was the first customer if the day).

Decent prices. Friendly service. Ok pizza.

Very tasty New York style pizza at a reasonable price on St Augustine Beach.

Best place for pizza on Anastasia Island. Very low key atmosphere if you're dinning in.

The people are super Friendly, and food is great, just think they should put a little more cheese on their pizzas

Worth the wait. Their pizza is some of the best New York style I've had.

Possibly the best pizza I've ever had.

I got a small green pepper pizza yesterday! Was delicious! Thin crust, tasty sauce and herbs, good cheese and the best pizza I’ve had in St Augustine! My new ‘go to’ pizza place!