Annapolis Ice Cream

Absolutely delicious ice cream in a cute little shop! Don’t miss this stop after lunch or dinner.

The new owners ruined everything good about this place. They used to have the best ice cream shop in Annapolis but 1) they changed the ice cream recipes (they’ll tell you they didn’t but that’s not true; the coconut in the coconut chocolate chip is now toasted when it didn’t used to be) 2) they got rid of all the penguins and decorated spoons that were fantastic decorations 3) they now cover up the glass on the ice cream cases so you can’t see the ice cream. They claim the new owners “don’t like the look of the ice cream boxes.” Who wants to buy ice cream that you can’t see? Super disappointed, I won’t be going here again despite it being my former favorite place for ice cream.

The place is pretty small with a few tables. The staff works pretty fast and you do not have to wait in the line too long. However, the ice cream is just average. I tried several flavors: blueberry, lime, lemon and chocolate. Blueberry tasted like a plain creamy ice cream, lime and lemon were lacking flavor but they were just a little bit sour. Chocolate was the best amomg all, but not the best I have ever had. All of them were too sweat and felt like they were made out of the same base by just adding some coloring. The guy at the register was so kind to change my blueberry ice cream with chocolate for free when I complained about it.

I had the most wonderful first time visit. All of the ice cream flavors were there that I could think of and more. I ordered Blackberry Cobbler and Black Raspberry. Sooooo delicious and you can tell that it's homemade. I will visit again. Some flavors change daily while others are not. Definitely worth the money!!

Been coming here since 2007. While the inside has definitely changes (i miss the wall of spoons) the ice cream remains the same. I was a little disappointed recently when I couldn't find the usual chocolate peanut butter ice cream but I am hoping that it will come back!

I've been here several times, I have no idea what's going on right now but last time I visited here (mid-December) I swear I saw employees are hiding somewhere like under the cashiers counter or other place. I don't know they're playing their phones or trying to make the store looks like closed. But the store did looked like closed so there was no one going in. If the owner had ever wondering why your sales are dropping perhaps that's the reason.

Why doesn't Maryland have more ice cream joints? They all seem to have congregated in Annapolis. I guess that makes it easier to visit them when they're all in the same place, but then I have to eat many scoops of ice cream. Perhaps they could borrow from the wineries and organize an "ice cream trail." I think folks would dig something like that. Bonus: all that walking helps burn off ice cream calories. Win-win. They could offer "tastings" and then I would get to try a variety of flavors. Annapolis Ice Cream Company strikes a nice balance between not enough variety and too many to choose from. And their ice cream is pretty good, too.

A good variety of ice cream just on the beautiful main Street of Annapolis. The portions are huge so just be aware when you are ordering a doubled or triple.

Great ice cream

Best homemade ice cream in Annapolis! Treat yourself

Both traditional and unique flavors. Strawberry Cheesecake is delicious with coconut chip, on the level. We as a group tried eleven flavors not one less than a 5 star version of flavor. Samples are free and plentiful to help you decide on a flavor. Great ice cream.

Delicious! Love their various flavor options. My son was so excited to try the blue "Cookie Monster" ice cream and it didn't disappoint!

Great service and the ice cream was delicious. Great recommendation from a cadet!

We had sweet potato pie, coffee Heath, Samoa and vanilla. All were very good. The sweet potato pie ice cream had candied pecans in it that were delicious!

The new owners took over a couple months ago and claimed they were keeping the same recipes and everything the same, however this is not true. It’s not at all the same and I’m honestly very disappointed. I don’t think it’s very fair for all of the accomplishments of the old owners to be used and put up by the new owners (ex. Voted best ice cream in Annapolis 20XX). It might have the same name, but this is not the same ice cream that I’ve been enjoying for over 10 years. However, employees are extremely kind and there is a vast amount of flavors for a good price.